You can answer one or multiple questions as you reflect on Chapters 17-20:

Do you agree or disagree with LT McDonough’s decision to send members of his Platoon to the beach? Should he have gone with them? Would it have made a difference? Are you surprised by the lack of consequences for his actions?

“They aren’t gooks, they’re Soldiers just like you and me.” This statement is made twice during Chapter 19, which one is more striking to you? Is this an important realization/reminder for LT McDonough? When LT McDonough states it is it for his own benefit or the young near-by lieutenant?

CPT Moray finally makes an appearance in Chapter 20. Based on the material we have covered in class what is your impression of him? What are his strengths and weaknesses and how do they effect his standing with LT McDonough? Is LT McDonough too aggressive as the Company prepares for the CPT’s final company-level operation?

Did something else stick out to you during these chapters? Feel free to ask your classmates some questions or reflect on what caught your attention.