Civil-Military Relations Start with Junior Leaders

Why Junior Leaders are the Frontline of Public Trust
Most lieutenants and captains don’t recognize their important role in stewarding the trust of the American public. Say “civil-military relations” or “civ-mil,” and they might picture congressional hearings or three- and four-star generals discussing war plans with secretaries. However, the junior officers and NCOs disciplining and norming the force are vital to keeping public trust in an ever more digitally connected military.
Recent headlines prove that these norms face continued friction at the tactical level. This summer, an Air Force officer was arrested after calling for the impeachment of President Trump in uniform on the Capitol steps. Last year, the Pentagon disciplined troops over social media posts about the Charlie Kirk assassination. An Army drill sergeant was investigated after posting training videos of trainees doing pushups under a banner that read “This Is Ultra MAGA Country.” These aren’t isolated events; they represent an ongoing erosion of personal and professional boundaries. Lieutenants and commanders often serve as the first line of response.
I’m sure you feel the pressure on your own timelines and algorithms. Now imagine what your Soldiers are seeing on theirs. Recent surveys involving officers and cadets revealed that about 1/3rd reported witnessing active-duty friends make or share disrespectful or disparaging remarks about the president or other political leader. This is conduct punishable under Article 88 of the UCMJ. It was a problem in the back of my Stryker in Germany in 2016, at Bragg in 2021, and unfortunately, I don’t think it’s been getting better.
Lesson 1: Constitutional foundations.
The foundation of American military service begins with the Oath of Office. Commissioned officers take a different oath than their enlisted counterparts. We swear an oath not to an individual leader, party, or administration, but to “support and defend the Constitution of the United States.” This oath establishes 3 necessary fundamental principles:
- Sovereignty is derived from the people. All legitimate governing authority originates from the citizenry. As the Constitution establishes, the people exercise their sovereignty through free and fair elections that choose their civilian leaders.
- Civilian Control of the Military. Because elected officials represent the sovereign will of the American people, the military must be subordinate to civilian authority. This civilian control of the military is foundational to our democratic liberty.
- Military personnel are legally and ethically bound to execute all lawful orders. Disagreement and doubts can and should be aired through appropriate channels, but once deemed lawful, faithfully executed. Your oath should guide you if you still have “any mental reservation.” Don’t be surprised if disobedience to a lawful order is punished.
Lesson 2: Public trust in the military is foundational to our Republic and civ-mil relations.
By this point, you’re probably asking why you should spend time on civ-mil norms with the competing demands of gunnery tables, layouts, and warfighting? The military’s operational effectiveness depends on public trust. Strong trust sustains the all-volunteer force, funds our readiness, and our legitimacy.
The American people trust the military with their sons and daughters, treasure, and the power to use lethal force. That trust is unusual compared to most other institutions of our democratic republic. The military remains among the most trusted institutions in American life, and that traces back to our oath. We commit to support and defend the Constitution; no person, nor party.
Soldiers must maintain a nonpartisan ethic. This does not mean being apolitical; the distinction is important. Soldiers don’t give up their rights as citizens. We can vote, join a party, and donate to candidates. Professionally, though, we must remain nonpartisan. Once a Soldier tries to use their position to sway someone else’s views on elections, voting, or partisan politics, whether digitally or face-to-face, they violate the standard. The public has trouble discerning one Soldier’s post from the institution.
Lesson 3: The Trust is Fragile.
You might assume that since we are the most trusted institution in the U.S., we can continue to weather any storm. Recent data shows a worrying trend. According to the most recent Reagan National Defense Survey, public confidence has continually declined since 2018. The survey highlights that only 67 % of Americans are confident the U.S. military can act in a professional and nonpolitical manner.
While measuring clear causation and correlation between social media misuse and declining public trust is difficult, some of our online footprints certainly don’t help. The rise of the mil-influencer, while occasionally a boon for recruiting when command- sanctioned, surely impacts what soldiers think they can get away with online. Seeing peers gain clout and endorsements through hot takes or viral commentary blurs the boundary between private speech and professional conduct.
Public trust is fragile, and social media allows soldiers a direct path to broadcast public grievance and partisan opinions. Preventing drift requires strong company-level leadership to educate the ranks, establish the norm, and steward professional conduct.
How to Norm the Ranks.
The baseline must be better than what I got as a Platoon leader: one bumper sticker and no partisan events in uniform. Norms are built every day in small corrections and counselings.
Soldiers need constant refreshers, especially around election season. Learn DoDD 1344.10, AR 600-20, and the Army’s personal social media guidance first. Set the standard and enforce it with your NCOs. Discussing what you are seeing on your own timelines is a great way to teach your Soldiers that these are challenges everyone encounters.
NCOs are the closest to the barracks and the cell phones. They see when venting drifts into public disrespect. A quiet, early correction beats a command investigation. Model good behavior and enforce standards evenly. Apply the standard the same way no matter who’s politics the post favors. Soldiers and the public notice when discipline bites one way.
What this leaves out.
Most of these cases are more complex than this article can address. Deciding whether an order is unlawful under the Law of Armed Conflict (LOAC) takes real study. The duty to refuse an illegal order is just as important as the duty to follow lawful ones you might dislike. Freedom of speech is important, but your Soldiers must understand that some of those freedoms were surrendered when they took their oath. When you hit one of these cases, talk to your commander, your NCOs, and your Staff Judge Advocate. Nobody announces the day this will be tested. It will be an ordinary Tuesday, a shared post or comment, and a leader who decides to say something.
Author Bio: MAJ Quinn Dilley is an instructor of American politics at the U.S. Military Academy at West Point and a Civil Affairs officer with operational experience in the Middle East and Africa. He holds an MPP from Duke University.
Photo: Courtesy of DVIDS. August 16, 2025 by Sgt. Tim Andrews
